This site uses cookies.  By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.   Find out more.

Protecting Plan Beneficiaries From Sponsor Bankruptcy

October 2013

Michael Rausch, CFA, ASA

BNY Mellon Investment Strategy and Solutions Group

What is the worst outcome for beneficiaries of a defined benefit pension plan? Simple. The worst outcome is not receiving the monthly benefit promised by the plan's sponsor. This can happen if a plan is not properly funded and its sponsor becomes insolvent. Given the potential of this combination of events to harm beneficiaries, sponsors could be expected to take steps to reduce this risk. Instead, many sponsors' investment strategies ignore and often enhance the risk. For example, according to a study by Pensions and Investments, the 200 largest corporate defined benefit plans allocate an average of 65 percent of their assets to stocks.1 As Figure 1 shows, corporate bankruptcies frequently increase at times when equity markets struggle.

Figure 1 // Correlation of U.S. Stock Market and U.S. Corporate Bankruptcy Index

Figure 1 // Correlation of U.S. Stock Market and U.S. Corporate Bankruptcy Index

Source: Bloomberg, Standard &Poor's. January 31, 2000 –July 31, 2013

The tendency of bankruptcies and bear markets to overlap shows that there is a real likelihood that some sponsors may go bankrupt while their plans are underfunded, which can mean reduced benefits for plan participants.

So what can sponsors do to better protect those beneficiaries? Investing in assets with a low or negative correlation to the sponsor's success may reduce the possibility that pension fund asset values will drop when a sponsor risks bankruptcy.


If the sponsor wants to reduce risk in this way, it can do so by purchasing "insurance" against itself. This insurance can be obtained through shorting the company's stock, purchasing put options on that stock, or buying credit default swaps tied to the company. While these investments are likely to provide beneficiaries with considerable protection if the company becomes insolvent, there are a host of other reasons why these investments are not practical or prudent. If the plan sponsor never becomes insolvent, these strategies will put a drag on the pension fund's overall performance due to their cost and lack of payout. It is also difficult for a corporate treasurer or chief financial officer to convince their board that shorting the company's stock is a prudent decision.


Since shorting company stock is probably not the best idea, let's focus on strategies that are much more prudent and still effective in protecting beneficiaries. Figure summarizes various investment strategies that corporate, public, and Taft-Hartley pension plan sponsors can implement.

Exhibit 2 // Realistic Investment Strategies to Help Protect Beneficiaries

All Corporate Sponsors Avoid stock or bond investments with high correlation to company success
  • Eliminate investments in plan sponsor stock or debt
  • Reduce or eliminate investments in stock or debt of companies within the plan sponsor's industry
Highly Cyclical Corporate Sponsors Avoid investments that are highly cyclical that may struggle when the company struggles
  • Reduce or eliminate investments in highly cyclical stocks
  • Reduce stock market exposure and invest in less cyclical asset classes such as absolute return or real return strategies
Corporate Sponsors Tied to Commodities Avoid direct investments in those commodities or other investments with high correlation to those commodities
  • Do not invest directly in the commodity
  • Avoid other commodities or companies that have a high correlation to the commodity that drives corporate profits
Public Sponsors Avoid investments that have a high correlation to the success of your tax base
  • Michigan public pension funds should avoid investments tied to the automobile industry
  • New York should consider reducing exposure to financial companies, Dallas or Houston should consider reduction in energy investments, and Pittsburgh should have avoided investments in the steel industry a half century ago
Taft-Hartley Sponsors Avoid investments that have a high correlation to the success of your tax base
  • The United Auto Workers may want to avoid investments in the automobile industry
  • The United Steelworkers may want to avoid investments in the steel industry


Plan sponsors may wonder how effectively their current investment strategy protects plan beneficiaries from the effects of a potential bankruptcy. There are both quantitative and qualitative ways to answer this question. A simple quantitative approach looks at a plan's historical funded status and compares it to the historical stock price of the sponsoring company. If the correlation is high, the exposure of beneficiaries to risk may also be. In Figure 3, we've applied this analysis to U.S. corporate defined benefit plans by measuring the correlation of the Standard &Poor's 500 Index and the funded status of pension plans sponsored by the companies that make up the S&P 500. The correlation between the two over the past 12 months is a very strong 0.91. This shows that, as a whole, the success of U.S. corporations is highly correlated to well-funded pension plans. When corporate profits are struggling and the S&P 500 Index falls, it is very likely that pension plans' funded status will worsen and create

Exhibit 3 // Performance of the S&P 500 and Funded Status of its Component Companies' Pension Plans

Exhibit 3 // Performance of the S&P 500 and Funded Status of its Component Companies' Pension Plans

Source: Bloomberg, Standard & Poor's, BNY Mellon ISSG. July 31, 2012–July 31, 2013

On the whole, U.S. corporations are doing very little to protect beneficiaries from the threat posed by corporate bankruptcy, but that is not necessarily true of all companies and all plans. We encourage all plan sponsors to use this analysis to determine if they need to do more. The inherent conflict between sponsors and beneficiaries sometimes causes those sponsors to lose sight of their purpose in investing pension assets and of whom they serve as fiduciaries. Pressure from corporations, taxpayers or unions also sometimes leads plan sponsors to forget that they must serve the best interest of plan beneficiaries. Analyzing how well they are protecting beneficiaries from bankruptcy can help them refocus on their true duty as pension plan fiduciaries.


1 Pensions & Investments, February 4, 2013: Based on the aggregate asset mixes for the top 200 defined benefit plans.

BNY Mellon Investment Management is one of the world's leading investment management organizations and one of the top U.S. wealth managers, encompassing BNY Mellon's affiliated investment management firms, wealth management organization and global distribution companies. BNY Mellon is the corporate brand of The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation and may also be used as a generic term to reference the Corporation as a whole or its various subsidiaries generally. · The statements and opinions expressed in this document are those of the authors as of the date of the article, are subject to change as economic and market conditions dictate, and do not necessarily represent the views of BNY Mellon, BNY Mellon Asset Management International or any of their respective affiliates. This document is of general nature, does not constitute legal, tax, accounting or other professional counsel or investment advice, is not predictive of future performance, and should not be construed as an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy any security or make an offer where otherwise unlawful. The information has been provided without taking into account the investment objective, financial situation or needs of any particular person. BNY Mellon Asset Management International Limited and its affiliates are not responsible for any subsequent investment advice given based on the information supplied.

Past performance is not a guide to future performance. The value of investments and the income from them is not guaranteed and can fall as well as rise due to stock market and currency movements. When you sell your investment you may get back less than you originally invested. · While the information in this document is not intended to be investment advice, it may be deemed a financial promotion in non-U.S. jurisdictions. Accordingly, where this document is used or distributed in any non-U.S. jurisdiction, the information provided is for use by professional and wholesale investors only and not for onward distribution to, or to be relied upon by, retail investors. · Products or services described in this document are provided by BNY Mellon, its subsidiaries, affiliates or related companies and may be provided in various countries by one or more of these companies where authorized and regulated as required within each jurisdiction. Not all products and services are offered at all locations. This document may not be distributed or used for the purpose of offers or solicitations in any jurisdiction or in any circumstances in which such offers or solicitations are unlawful or not authorized, or where there would be, by virtue of such distribution, new or additional registration requirements. Persons into whose possession this document comes are required to inform themselves about and to observe any restrictions that apply to the distribution of this document in their jurisdiction. The investment products and services mentioned here are not insured by the FDIC (or any other state or federal agency), are not deposits of or guaranteed by any bank, and may lose value. · This document should not be published in hard copy, electronic form, via the web or in any other medium accessible to the public, unless authorized by BNY Mellon Investment Management International Limited.

In Australia, this document is issued by BNY Mellon Investment Management Australia Ltd (ABN 56 102 482 815, AFS License No. 227865) located at Level 6, 7 Macquarie Place, Sydney, NSW 2000. Authorized and regulated by the Australian Securities &Investments Commission. · In Brazil, this document is issued by BNY Mellon Serviços Financeiros DTVM S.A., Av. Presidente Wilson, 231, 11th floor, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil, CEP 20030-905. BNY Mellon Serviços Financeiros DTVM S.A. is a Financial Institution, duly authorized by the Brazilian Central Bank to provide securities distribution and by the Brazilian Securities and Exchange Commission (CVM) to provide securities portfolio managing services under Declaratory Act No. 4.620, issued on December 19, 1997. · Securities in Canada are offered through BNY Mellon Asset Management Canada Ltd., registered as a Portfolio Manager and Exempt Market Dealer in all provinces and territories of Canada, and as an Investment Fund Manager in Ontario. · In Dubai, United Arab Emirates, this document is issued by the Dubai branch of The Bank of New York Mellon, which is regulated by the Dubai Financial Services Authority. This material is intended for Professional Clients only and no other person should act upon it. · If this document is used or distributed in Hong Kong, it is issued by BNY Mellon Investment Management Hong Kong Limited, whose business address is Level 18, Three Pacific Place, 1 Queen's Road East, Hong Kong. BNY Mellon Investment Management Hong Kong Limited is regulated by the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission and its registered office is at 6th floor, Alexandra House, 18 Chater Road, Central, Hong Kong. · In Japan, this document is issued by BNY Mellon Asset Management Japan Limited, Marunouchi Trust Tower Main Building, 1-8-3 Marunouchi Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo 100-0005, Japan. BNY Mellon Asset Management Japan Limited is a Financial Instruments Business Operator with license no 406 (Kinsho) at the Commissioner of Kanto Local Finance Bureau and is a Member of the Investment Trusts Association, Japan and Japan Securities Investment Advisers Association. · In Korea, this document is issued by BNY Mellon AM Korea Limited for presentation to professional investors. BNY Mellon AM Korea Limited, 29F One IFC, 10 Gukegeumyung-ro, Yeongdeungpo-gu, Seoul, 150-945, Korea. Regulated by the Financial Supervisory Service. · In Singapore, this document is issued by The Bank of New York Mellon, Singapore Branch for presentation to accredited investors, institutional investors and family offices that are expert investors as defined under the Securities and Futures Act. The Bank of New York Mellon, Singapore Branch, One Temasek Avenue, #02-01 Millenia Tower, Singapore 039192. Regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore. · This document is issued in the UK and in mainland Europe, by BNY Mellon Asset Management International Limited, 160 Queen Victoria Street, London EC4V 4LA. Registered in England No. 1118580. Authorized and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. · This document is issued in the United States by BNY Mellon Investment Management.

BNY Mellon owns over 95% of the parent holding company of The Alcentra Group, which is comprised of the following affiliated investment advisers: Alcentra, Ltd and Alcentra NY, LLC. · BNY Mellon Cash Investment Strategies is a division of The Dreyfus Corporation. · BNY Mellon Western FMC, Insight Investment Management Limited and Meriten Investment Management GmbH do not offer services in the U.S. This presentation does not constitute an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to purchase, any of the firms' services or funds to any U.S. investor, or where otherwise unlawful. · BNY Mellon Western Fund Management Company Limited is a joint venture between BNY Mellon (49%) and China based Western Securities Company Ltd. (51%). The firm does not offer services outside of the People's Republic of China. · BNY Mellon owns 90% of The Boston Company Asset Management, LLC and the remainder is owned by employees of the firm. · BNY Mellon owns a 19.9% minority interest in The Hamon Investment Group Pte Limited, the parent company of Blackfriars Asset Management Limited and Hamon Asian Advisors Limited both of which offer investment services in the U.S. · Services offered in the US, Canada and Australia by Pareto Investment Management Limited under the Insight Pareto brand. · The Newton Group ("Newton") is comprised of the following affiliated companies: Newton Investment Management Limited, Newton Capital Management Limited (NCM Ltd), Newton Capital Management LLC (NCM LLC), Newton International Investment Management Limited and Newton Fund Managers (C.I.) Limited. NCM LLC personnel are supervised persons of NCM Ltd and NCM LLC does not provide investment advice, all of which is conducted by NCM Ltd. Only NCM LLC and NCM Ltd offer services in the U.S. · BNY Mellon owns a 20% interest in Siguler Guff &Company, LP and certain related entities (including Siguler Guff Advisers LLC). · BNY Mellon Asset Management International Limited and any other BNY Mellon entity mentioned above are all ultimately owned by BNY Mellon, unless otherwise noted.

© 2013 The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation. All rights reserved.